Medela Pump In Style: Common Concerns & Better Pump Alternatives

If you’re searching for the best breast pump, you’ve likely come across the Medela Pump In Style. It’s been around for years, and many moms receive it through insurance. But is it the best option for maintaining a strong breast milk supply? Probably not. In fact, most mothers that I see that have this pump are often struggling with supply due to its poor suction.

As an IBCLC in Boise, I’ve worked with many pumping moms who have struggled with low milk supply, poor suction, and discomfort using the Pump In Style. While it may work for some, there are better pump options that provide more comfort, efficiency, and long-term reliability.

Let’s dive into the common concerns with the Medela Pump In Style and explore some better breast pump alternatives that can help you pump more milk with less frustration.

Concerns About the Medela Pump In Style

1. Weak or Inconsistent Suction

One of the biggest complaints about the Pump In Style is that the suction isn’t as strong or consistent as other double electric breast pumps like the Spectra or Motif Luna. Many moms report that it:

❌ Loses suction over time

❌ Doesn’t fully empty the breasts, leading to a drop in milk supply

❌ Feels less effective than older Medela models

2. Loud & Noisy Motor

If you plan to pump at work or during baby’s nap, keep in mind that the Pump In Style is loud. While some moms don’t mind the sound, others find it distracting—especially compared to quieter breast pumps like the Spectra S1 or S2.

3. Less Comfortable for Some Moms

Flange fit is crucial for pumping success, and the Pump In Style comes with hard plastic flanges that aren’t always comfortable. Other brands, like Spectra, offer softer, more flexible flanges that reduce discomfort and improve milk flow.

4. Battery Pack Doesn’t Last Long

Many moms choose the Pump In Style because it’s portable, but its battery pack isn’t very strong. If you’re pumping away from an outlet, you might notice a drop in suction strength, making it harder to express milk efficiently.

5. Open System vs. Closed System

The Pump In Style has an open system, meaning milk can potentially enter the tubing, leading to mold growth and contamination if not properly cleaned. Many modern pumps, like Spectra and Motif Luna, use a closed system, which is more hygienic and prevents milk backflow.

Better Breast Pump Alternatives

If you’re looking for a pump that offers stronger suction, better comfort, and improved milk removal, here are some of the best alternatives to the Medela Pump In Style:

1. Spectra S1 or S2 (Best Overall for Milk Supply & Comfort)

✔ Why Moms Love It:

    •    Hospital-strength suction for better milk removal

    •    Quieter motor than Medela

    •    Closed system for hygiene

    •    Rechargeable battery (S1 model)

Best For: Moms who pump multiple times a day, need a comfortable pump, and want to maximize supply.

2. Motif Luna (Best Affordable Alternative)

✔ Why Moms Love It:

    •    Strong suction similar to Spectra

    •    More compact & lightweight

    •    Quieter than Medela

    •    Comes with soft, flexible flanges for better comfort

Best For: Moms who want a hospital-strength pump with a quieter motor and softer flanges.

3. Baby Buddha (Best for Power & Portability)

✔ Why Moms Love It:

    •    Super strong suction (more than Medela or Spectra)

    •    Small and ultra-portable

    •    Rechargeable battery lasts longer than Medela’s

Best For: Moms who need a powerful pump that’s easy to carry and use anywhere.

4. Medela Symphony (Best for Exclusive Pumping & Low Supply)

✔ Why Moms Love It:

    •    Hospital-grade suction for maximum milk output

    •    Most efficient Medela pump

    •    Preferred by IBCLCs for moms with low milk supply

Best For: Moms who are exclusively pumping or need to increase milk supply quickly (often available for rental).

Final Thoughts: Should You Get the Medela Pump In Style?

While the Medela Pump In Style works for some moms, it may not be the best choice if you need:

• Stronger suction to fully empty your breasts

• A quieter pump for work or night pumping

• A more comfortable fit with flexible flanges

• A longer-lasting battery for portability

• A closed system for better hygiene

  If you’re struggling with pumping or low supply, switching to a stronger, more efficient breast pump like the Spectra S1, Motif Luna, or Baby Buddha can make a huge difference.

Need help choosing the best pump for your breastfeeding journey? As a Boise IBCLC, I can help you find the right pump and ensure you’re using it correctly. Schedule a lactation consultation today at BoiseLactation.com or call 971-235-8773.